Sirens

Britne Oldford

Missy

Bill Camp

Bruce DeWitt

Meghann Fahy

Devon DeWitt

Julianne Moore

Michaela Kell

Milly Alcock

Simone DeWitt

Kevin Bacon

Peter Kell

Glenn Howerton

Ethan Corbin II

Felix Solis

Jose

Josh Segarra

Raymond

Trevor F. Salter

Jordan/Morgan

Lauren Weedman

Patrice

Patrick Voss Davis

Eddy

Jenn Lyon

Cloe

Erin Neufer

Lisa

Emily Borromeo

Astrid

Catherine Cohen

Lily-Rose

Meghan O'Leary-Clark

Officer Coffin

Juan Carlos Infante

Cyrus

Jason Dietz

Joel

Adam Harrington

Perfect Dad

Remy Auberjonois

Phil

Domenic Servidio

Paul

Jennifer Noble

Allie

Mike Boland

Greg

Miranda Roldán

Kelly Ricchio

J. Richey Nash

Kenny

Megan Ketch

Susan Davenport

Tate Kenney

Tate

Shivani Shah

Melanie

Feruza Ari

Pastry Chef

Ann Carr

Bella

Mikella Matthias

Sous Chef

Taylor Shurte

Andrea (uncredited)